Messy cables in a classroom.

Early in 2020, I wrote about my experiences of shifting to on-line studying: studying to make use of new instruments, altering the way in which I taught, and coping with the challenges of distant evaluation. Sitting, unmentioned within the background, was the truth that the school the place I educate had already agreed to revamp our electrical engineering curriculum, which directs the lives of scholars throughout three of their 4 years right here. This raised a relatively important query: can we keep on with the outdated in these attempting instances, or forge forward with one thing new? Ultimately, we determined that we might press on with the brand new.

Then, simply so as to add to the confusion, administration determined that we must always have two scholar intakes: one in August/September (the standard beginning time for brand spanking new college students), and one in February. This meant that, if we had been quick sufficient, we may trial the brand new curriculum on a small group of scholars that began in February, relatively than leaping within the deep finish in September. After a variety of work, and with a lot materials nonetheless to be developed, we predict we’re able to roll.

Top-of-the-line components of growing the brand new curriculum has been the criticism and suggestions we’ve had from colleagues, college students, and alumni. Now, with a month to go earlier than we’ll be utilizing the brand new curriculum, I wish to open it as much as critique by you, the Ars readers. I’m able to be the Christmas roast.

Out with the outdated

Our outdated curriculum may be very conventional. We slog by programs of conventional lectures, backed up by sensible workouts that, hopefully, hyperlink the speculation to apply. The scholars do venture work all through their diploma. These tasks are a bit like an overgrown vestigial organ: they take a variety of work, however, so far as the scholars are involved, don’t have a variety of performance.

Our evaluation can also be very conventional. Virtually each topic has a written examination. The ultimate grade is completely decided by the examination, so long as the coed has additionally obtained a passing grade on their sensible workouts.

We persistently rating low in scholar satisfaction, and we’ve a better than common drop-out charge in first yr. College students typically overlook the relevance of what’s taught. Moreover, our college students typically fail to understand the hyperlinks between the totally different topics. Whereas the scholars aren’t overjoyed, employers that take our graduates are joyful, observing that they appear to have the fitting talent set.

The query for us: how can we enhance our supply, in order that we scale back the weaknesses, however nonetheless graduate college students which have the fitting talent set?

In with the brand new

We determined that we might drag our curriculum out of the 19th century and squarely into the 20th (schooling is conservative, so child steps). The primary change was to scrap all of the programs. We now not provide “analog electronics” or something alongside these strains. These have been changed with a set of “studying outcomes.” A studying final result is a press release about what a scholar can do. As a way to get their examine credit, a scholar has to exhibit to our satisfaction that they can do.

To take a selected instance, one in every of our studying outcomes reads “You may design, simulate, create and characterize a DC community of passive elements with a specified response.” That may be a relatively obscure assertion, however it’s backed up by a sequence of extra detailed statements that inform the coed precisely what we anticipate to see. As an example, the coed ought to exhibit that they’ll simulate a DC circuit, that they’ll carry out correct measurements on the circuit, that they’ll hand-calculate the voltages and currents at any node within the circuit, and extra.

How the coed does that’s, to a big diploma, as much as them: they merely should ship proof of their mastery of a studying final result. To assist the scholars, we offer them with group tasks which might be outlined solely by way of a theme (e.g., healthcare). The scholar group will get to find out the main points of the venture. The scholars tackle the portion of the venture that is linked to their studying outcomes. In different phrases, a scholar that wishes to pursue analog electronics can work on no matter analog electronics are wanted to finish the healthcare venture. They’ll use their contribution to the venture as proof of an analog electronics studying final result. The method is illustrated under.

Process of going from learning outcome to project activities to assessment.
Enlarge / Technique of going from studying final result to venture actions to evaluation.

Chris Lee

Sustaining requirements, preserving freedom

This offers college students a variety of freedom, however that must be balanced towards instructional necessities. We’ve to make sure that the scholars attain a minimal commonplace. To make sure that we do that, the scholars have to explain what they’re going to do of their venture, and this description must be signed off by their venture mentor and a subject-matter professional. So, if a scholar desires to acquire their analog electronics studying final result, they should suggest one thing that meets the usual set by an analog electronics professional. That is all compiled right into a (digital) studying settlement that’s signed by all events.

One problem is that college students who’re obsessive about one side {of electrical} engineering might neglect different areas. The consequence could be one-dimensional college students who’re completely blind to a number of the fundamentals in different areas. To keep away from this, we’ve designated sure studying outcomes as necessary and each scholar has to realize these. In that means, we cowl the basics {of electrical} engineering.

Even with the necessary element, nonetheless, we nonetheless have practically half the credit obtainable for electives. Elective studying outcomes are clean. The scholars are anticipated to put in writing their very own studying final result, together with describing the proof that can exhibit their mastery of the educational final result. That implies that college students can take conventional programs at different institutes, and even use their work at an organization as a part of their schooling.

The boundary situation is that we (the academics) should agree. The scholar’s studying final result must be accepted by their mentor and a subject-matter professional. The approval course of ensures that the coed nonetheless has adequate breadth of information once they graduate. The entire course of is illustrated under.

How learning outcomes and learning agreements are formulated and agreed.
Enlarge / How studying outcomes and studying agreements are formulated and agreed.

Chris Lee

This offers the scholars the prospect to have interaction with areas that basically curiosity them, hopefully growing their satisfaction. It additionally encourages them to think about their schooling by way of life after college. They should justify their decisions to themselves and their mentors.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here