Mary Barra, CEO of General Motors, in 2019.
Enlarge / Mary Barra, CEO of Normal Motors, in 2019.

Patrick T. Fallon/Bloomberg by way of Getty Pictures

GM CEO Mary Barra on Monday signaled that the corporate is standing by its deal to supply Nikola’s Badger pickup truck.

“The corporate has labored with a number of totally different companions and we’re a really succesful group that has achieved the suitable diligence,” Barra said throughout a convention with RBC Capital Markets on Monday.

GM is standing by Nikola regardless of current revelations that the startup misled the general public concerning the capabilities of its first truck, the Nikola One. At its 2016 unveiling, founder Trevor Milton claimed that the Nikola One “absolutely features.” However on Monday, Nikola admitted that the corporate by no means had a working prototype of the truck. The corporate acknowledged {that a} 2018 promotional video confirmed the truck rolling down a shallow hill—not driving underneath its personal energy.

So why is not GM backing away from the Nikola deal? It poses little or no threat for GM. GM is not investing a dime in Nikola; as an alternative, all the cash will move the opposite approach.

“For GM, there’s actually no draw back to the deal,” mentioned Sam Abuelsamid, an auto trade analyst at Guidehouse. “It is all upside.”

The deal’s phrases are extraordinarily pleasant to GM

Underneath the deal, Nikola can pay GM as much as $700 million to cowl the price of constructing manufacturing capability for Nikola’s Badger truck. Nikola will then pay GM much more cash to fabricate the autos on a cost-plus foundation.

The battery-electric model of the Badger shall be primarily based on GM’s Ultium battery platform, which GM will presumably promote to Nikola at a revenue. Not solely will the hydrogen model of the Badger be primarily based on GM’s Hydrotec gasoline cell expertise, however GM may also turn out to be the unique provider of hydrogen gasoline cells for Nikola’s semi vehicles (exterior Europe) for a four-year interval.

These are applied sciences that GM was planning to develop anyway, so the deal offers GM an opportunity to do it partly at one other firm’s expense. Even when Nikola had been to exit of enterprise in a yr or two, GM would achieve priceless information and expertise—and would possibly be capable of use the Nikola-funded services to make its personal pickup vehicles.

Abuelsamid predicts that GM will construct the Badger in Detroit alongside GM’s personal electrical autos equivalent to the electrical Hummer and the Chevy electrical pickup truck. Extra quantity will improve GM’s economies of scale.

“The extra autos you may construct and promote, the much less fastened price related to every unit,” Abuelsamid mentioned.

On high of the direct funds to fabricate the Badger, Nikola can also be giving GM $2 billion in inventory. The contract requires GM to carry the inventory for at the least a yr after the deal closes. GM will be capable of promote a 3rd of the inventory after one yr, one other third after two years, and the ultimate third on the conclusion of the deal—presumably as late as 2025.

On high of that, GM will get to retain 80 % of the dear electrical car regulatory credit from the Badger vehicles.

On the identical time, the deal is structured to attenuate dangers to GM’s repute. The Badger shall be branded as a Nikola product, not a GM product. Nikola will be responsible for gross sales and repair of the Badger truck in addition to the guarantee. So if clients have issues with the truck—or Nikola fails to ship vehicles in any respect—individuals will complain to Nikola, not GM.

The deal offers Nikola a repute increase

Nikola additionally positive aspects some advantages from the deal—although the character of these advantages depends upon how cynical you might be about Nikola’s motivations.

“Up till the announcement final week, the Badger was full vaporware,” Abuelsamid advised me. Nikola would not have in-house capability to develop a pickup truck. And as Tesla has realized, it takes years and prices billions of {dollars} to construct manufacturing capability for a shopper car. The GM partnership provides a shortcut for Nikola to convey its truck to market.

The GM deal offers Nikola expertise promoting an actual pickup truck to actual clients. Maybe Nikola can use the expertise from the Badger to assist it manufacture its personal vehicles down the highway. Or possibly the Nikola model shall be so compelling that Nikola can flip a revenue by promoting vehicles manufactured by others indefinitely.

The extra cynical interpretation is that Trevor Milton merely needed to have the ability to say that he had a take care of GM. Milton has made himself a paper billionaire by convincing traders that Nikola is on the trail to be the following Tesla. Simply with the ability to say they’ve a take care of GM is probably going to offer Nikola added credibility with much less savvy traders even when the phrases of the deal are wildly unfavorable to Nikola.

It is not unusual for worthwhile firms to outsource manufacturing to others—take a look at Apple outsourcing iPhone manufacturing, for instance. However Apple’s beneficiant revenue margins come from the truth that the iPhone is constructed largely on chips and software program that Apple itself invented.

Nikola, against this, is paying GM to construct vehicles largely primarily based on GM applied sciences. It is onerous to make a big revenue simply reselling merchandise designed and manufactured by different firms. However hundreds of Robinhood day merchants won’t notice that.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here