A woman is wearing a mask with the Uyghurs flag on it, during the demonstration 'Freedom for Uyghurs' in The Hague, Netherlands on August 20th, 2020.
Enlarge / A lady is carrying a masks with the Uyghurs flag on it, in the course of the demonstration ‘Freedom for Uyghurs’ in The Hague, Netherlands on August twentieth, 2020.

Romy Arroyo Fernandez/NurPhoto through Getty Pictures

Twitter has instructed Ars Technica {that a} Chinese government tweet praising China’s therapy of its Uygur ethnic minority doesn’t violate its coverage towards hateful conduct.

“Research exhibits that within the strategy of eradicating extremism, the minds of Uygur ladies in Xinjiang had been emancipated and gender equality and reproductive well being had been promoted, making them not baby-making machines,” the tweet says. “They’re extra assured and unbiased.”

Human rights advocates have characterised China’s therapy of the Uygur individuals within the Xinjiang area of China as a demographic genocide. This is how the Related Press described China’s strategy final summer season:

The state commonly topics minority ladies to being pregnant checks, and forces intrauterine gadgets, sterilization and even abortion on a whole lot of 1000’s, interviews and knowledge present. Even whereas the usage of IUDs and sterilization has fallen nationwide, it’s rising sharply in Xinjiang.

The inhabitants management measures are backed by mass detention each as a menace and as a punishment for failure to conform. Having too many youngsters is a significant cause individuals are despatched to detention camps, the AP discovered, with the dad and mom of three or extra ripped away from their households except they will pay enormous fines. Police raid properties, terrifying dad and mom as they seek for hidden youngsters.

Thursday’s tweet from the Chinese language Embassy in the US hyperlinks to an article within the China Each day, a publication of the Chinese language Communist Celebration, that disputes these claims. The article claims that as China has eradicated “spiritual extremism” from the area, Uygur ladies have freely chosen to make use of contraception extra, resulting in a decline in beginning charges within the area. It dismisses claims by “some Western students and politicians” that China has engaged in compelled sterilizations of Uygurs.

Twitter commonly takes down content material that violates its guidelines. Twitter’s rule towards hateful conduct states that customers “could not promote violence towards or instantly assault or threaten different individuals on the premise of race,” ethnicity, or faith. Customers are additionally not allowed to “goal people and teams with content material supposed to incite concern or unfold fearful stereotypes a few protected class”—reminiscent of “all [religious group] are terrorists.”

Twitter additionally bans “the dehumanization of a gaggle of individuals” primarily based on their faith, race, or ethnicity.

On Thursday night, I emailed Twitter to ask whether or not the tweet ran afoul of the foundations. A Twitter spokesman shortly responded to say that it didn’t. “This Tweet just isn’t in violation of our insurance policies,” he wrote to Ars.

Twitter’s guidelines are imprecise sufficient that it is arduous to say for certain whether or not the tweet violates the letter of the insurance policies. It does not explicitly name for violence towards the Uygur minority. Certainly it insists that the Uygurs have not been victims of violence or dehumanization in any respect. On the similar time, claiming that Uygur ladies had been being held again by “extremist” views that turned them into “baby-making machines” does appear somewhat dehumanizing. And Twitter may wish to bear in mind not solely the literal phrases of the tweet but in addition the broader context of the Chinese language authorities’s actions within the Xinjiang area.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here